Thursday, January 7, 2010

Let's stop sending each other on guilt trips...

Recently in the UK, controversial billboards which read "Career Women Make Bad Mothers" were withdrawn by the Outdoor Advertising Association.

The billboards, which were part of an OAA campaign designed to promote the effectiveness of billboard advertising, unsurprisingly caused an outcry from working mothers.



According to a UK mother's network, working women were left feeling anger, disappointment, even despair.

Feelings undoubtably due to the guilt most mothers are made to feel at some stage in their life - usually by other mothers, and often by those who aren't yet mothers.

The stay-at-home-mum versus working-mother debate has been an issue of contention for some time now, with each group judging the other as somehow inferior.

Stay-at-home mums are not ambitious, working mums are selfish - or so they say.

I am extremely fortunate to be able to work from home, but have learnt the hard way, that motherhood issues are not simply black and white.

I do admit though, to having pre-set opinions and ideas prior to becoming a mum, only to fall victim of the judgement of others after having my son.

I was going to stay home with my baby and I was going to breast feed.

It was the breast feeding idea that didn't quite go to plan. In the end I only breast fed my baby for a short time, before switching to the dreaded bottle.

To address what most are usually thinking at this point - no I did not find it too painful (although it was very much so) and simply give up.

It wasn't all about technique either - the midwives confirmed this - despite the resulting damage.

I did, however, end up with severe and recurring mastitis.

And yes, I am aware that continuing to breast feed is the best way to cure mastitis.

Which is exactly what I did. However in my particular case, continuing to feed and continuous antibiotics did not improve the condition.

It got worse, my son was not getting enough milk and I ended up in hospital - away from my new baby - for days.

And it was on doctor's advice (*gasp) that I gave up breast feeding - with complete agreement from the midwife (*bigger gasp) treating my mastitis.

I was wracked with guilt, despite weeks of intense physical pain.

And I've lost count of the number of women who have informed me, upon hearing my son was being bottle fed, that they had mastitis/pain/difficulties, but they persevered "and it DOES get easier".

They don't know my story - and I don't always share it - but that's just it. We don't know each other's situation so why do we judge?

I choose to stay home with my son, but I don't feel superior to those who work full-time, nor should they feel superior to me.

And these are just two of the many issues we regularly judge each other on.

There's dummies, home-made vs commercial baby food, controlled crying, routine vs demand feeding, childcare, use of babysitters, how long we keep bub in our room - the list goes on.

We're all entitled to an opinion, but that doesn't mean we have to turn up our nose to those who choose a different path.

The majority of mothers are simply doing the best they can, to provide the best lives for their little bundles of joy.

Let's support each other instead of sending each other on never ending guilt trips.

As they say, there isn't a handbook and as long as we're doing our best, that's the best we can do.

6 comments:

  1. Well said Nic! I get so sick of the judgemental attitude some (not all) people have. Our paediatrician was supportive of my decision to bottlefeed both of my girls after breastfeeding didn't work out. For something that is supposed to be so natural it's very hard! My girls are both healthy and growing well so I don't regret my decision.

    It really is an individual decision and different people have different circumstances or reasons as to why they choose to breastfeed or not. I really think it's awful that there is so much pressure and judgement on parents. Especially online parenting forums - they are the WORST for this! We're damned if we do and damned if we don't!

    KylieD

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Nicole,

    I'm a new reader and pleased I have stumbled across your blog.

    Here here to your comments. As a mother I agree the majority of mothers are simply doing their BEST minus a 'manual'. Some without their own mother or family to turn to for support and advice. I can't imagine how difficult this would be at times. I wonder whether the guilt trip we are often sent on is a means used to justify someone else's insecurities.

    I don't think many of us are well prepared for the parenting journey. At times it's a tough road and at others a life never to be replaced.

    The ideal would seem to support each other along the way without judgement.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Nicole - I agree with your sentiments here, each to their own. Becoming a mother isn't a competition!! I hate how women feel the need to be competitive with other women. What ever happened to the sistahood?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Nicole
    I hopped to your blog, based on your post on LinkedIn's Magazine group. I have also provided the url to my blog, feel free to visit, whenever time permits.
    I am so glad this advertisement was withdrawn. It was outrageous. As humans we judge each other and perhaps too quickly on a wide variety of issues.
    Be it motherhood, or taking a sabbatical (which I had taken). Friendly criticism is welcome, but unwanted judgements? Nah.
    Have a nice Sunday.
    Best,
    Lubna
    http://writerscyberslate.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm with you on that! Ignorance combined with a healthy dose of arrogance - just can;t beat it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi there
    this is a really good post.
    Although I am a single woman with no kids, I have seen the good mother vs bad mother debate by people I know.
    Aside from the career/stay at home mum guilt, there is also the guilt we put on each other about looks and just how much we fit into our lives.
    You've only got to think about the reaction to Jen Hawkins non-retouched on Marie Claire. We gave her grief for looking beautiful. We wanted to see 'real women' on the cover. Yet we give ourselves and other women grief for not being an (our?) ideal shape/weight/look.
    It's time we forgot the guilt trips and just be happy for our ability to live a life happily and healthily.
    Carly
    http://carlyfindlay.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete

I'd love to hear your thoughts...please leave a comment

About Me

My photo
Nicole is an Australian journalist, presenter and communications consultant. She spent several years as a News Limited journalist, writing for a variety of local newspapers and magazines. Following this, Nicole was a reporter and presenter with the Nine Network, filing stories for Brisbane magazine program Extra, lifestyle show Weekend Extra and National Nine News. She is now a freelance journalist, writing for a variety of publications. Her special interests are features, lifestyle, current affairs, women, parenting/family and health. Nicole is also a public relations and communications consultant. www.nicolemadigan.webs.com
Related Posts with Thumbnails